“I don’t want to be reliant on medication.”
I’d told my therapist that just a few months earlier.
But when she suggests I start on an antidepressant, I immediately say yes.
“I can’t believe I have to take a pill every day to be happy.”
This thought races through my head a few weeks after starting it. It’s working, but I hate that I have to take a pill to feel “normal”.
“Is taking mental health medication a sin?”
I type this into Google at 2 am while the guilt and shame threaten to overtake me. Shouldn’t my faith be enough?
This is for anyone who’s ever wondered if taking medication for mental health means you have weak faith.
Spoiler alert: it doesn’t.
We’d never think twice about taking a pill for a headache. So, why does this feel different?
Nobody Questions the Heart Medication
If your doctor prescribes blood pressure medication, you take it. No one asks whether that means you don’t trust God.
Taking ibuprofen for sore muscles isn’t a sin. Neither is cough syrup for a cold.
It took me months to find the right medication for my depression, and that was after a genetic test showing how my body processes different medications. It still took trial and error to land on the right dose.
That isn’t unusual. Plenty of people take months to get their blood pressure medication right, too.
In 2017, I wrote in my journal: “Why can I call in sick to miss work when I have the flu, but not when I’m depressed?”
That double standard tells us to “push through” mental illness. We’d never do that with a fever.
Why do we treat mental health medication as a faith failure?
Where My Shame Came From
In 2014, a year after losing my young cousin, Maddy, to cancer, I was away at college, falling into depression, and didn’t realize it. I wrote in my journal: “It feels like giving up if I get counseling.” I needed help, but starting therapy felt like “caving in.” I treated needing help as losing.
Then there’s church culture, which can make it sound like a strong Christian shouldn’t need help, so needing it must mean something is wrong with your faith.
The loudest of those voices was my own.
Every one of them assumes faith means not needing any outside help. But this idea doesn’t come from the Bible.
Why Taking Medication Isn’t a Sin
In Isaiah 38, King Hezekiah was sick and at the point of death. He turned his face to the wall, prayed, and wept. God heard him and promised to add 15 years to his life (Isaiah 38:5). God could have healed him with a word. Instead, Isaiah gave instructions to put a poultice of figs on his boil, and he recovered (Isaiah 38:21). (By the way, a poultice is a soft paste you spread on the skin. I had to look it up too!)
The healing and the treatment came together. God answered Hezekiah’s prayer through a remedy.
Nobody in the story treats the figs as a lack of faith. They were part of how God answered.
So, is taking medication a sin? Hezekiah’s story says no. Your mental health medication can be part of how God answers your prayers too.
And medication is only one form of treatment.
Therapy Is Wise Counsel
On December 8, 2014, I wrote: “I’m trying to rely on God to get through this, but I feel like I need to talk about it with another person who can give me advice.”
Maddy had died a year earlier, and my Aunt Terry was just given a terminal diagnosis. I was away at college and struggling while my aunt was actively dying, still resisting therapy but wondering if it would help.
Proverbs 15:22 says, “Plans fail for lack of counsel, but with many advisers they succeed.”
A good therapist is one of those advisers.
It took the worst night I’d ever had, two months later, to make me finally call. I remember breaking down during my intake. It was the first time I voiced everything I had been carrying and feeling, and it all came out like a dam breaking.
My favorite therapist in college helped me visualize a pile of all my negative emotions, depression, and grief. I had told her it was too overwhelming, and I’ll never forget that she told me to take a few “things” from the pile at a time and leave the rest in the corner for later.
In time, the pile grew smaller and smaller.
In July 2016, I wrote: “It feels so good to actually know what’s going on with me. I finally can read myself.”
Therapy helped me to identify my own emotions and work through them with God. I didn’t realize it at the time, but God held me up even when I thought I couldn’t keep going.
Going to therapy and getting help is wisdom. Not weakness.
What Medication Was Like for Me
I had never really thought twice about taking medication when I was younger. I’d pop Tylenols all the time for headaches, whereas now, you’ll find me chugging a jug of water, massaging my shoulders, and taking a nap before thinking about taking Tylenol.
When it came to mental health medication, or antidepressants for me, I was very resistant to the idea.
But by the time my therapist suggested them to me in 2017, I was so depressed and suicidal that I didn’t care what it took. I just wanted to feel better. I couldn’t go a week without a panic attack, and the depression made it impossible for me to function. My lifeline was the idea of antidepressants.
The first one I took started working within weeks, and it was amazing.
But then the fear set in. The thought from the beginning of this post came back every night before I took my meds: “It’s scary that I have to rely on this to be happy.”
I felt like I was relying on a little yellow pill instead of God.
In 2018, my antidepressants stopped working, and I had to switch. The night before my appointment, I wrote: “I need [antidepressants] to be normal, and I don’t know what else I could do if they weren’t an option.”
And now? After being on antidepressants for almost 10 years? Taking my nightly Zoloft is just part of my routine. I haven’t had a panic attack in about a year. When one does come, I know how to ride it out, and it’s over in about five minutes.
I don’t feel shame or fear for taking medication. God provided a way for me to be happy again, and it’s not a failure to trust Him.
Just like Hezekiah and his fig poultice, my Zoloft helps me function and survive.
If you’re having thoughts of suicide or you’re in crisis, call or text 988 to reach the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline. You don’t have to be in danger to reach out.
Pray and Take the Pill
You are allowed to pray and take medication, just like you can go to church and therapy.
In 1 Timothy 5:23, Paul, who saw God heal people, still told Timothy to take a little wine for his stomach. Prayer and a remedy sit in the same letter.
We don’t have to choose between faith and medication, therapy, EMDR, or whatever else helps us heal.
God could 100% have taken my depression away, regardless of how strong my faith was. Healing isn’t a reward for “strong enough” faith. While I never want to feel that way again, I’m almost glad I experienced it so I have a testimony to share with all of you.
If you’re still in it, you don’t have to feel that way about yours.
You’re Allowed to Get Help
If you feel ashamed every time you pick up your pill bottle or schedule a therapy appointment, hear this: you’re allowed to get help. Taking a pill or talking with a professional says nothing about the strength of your faith.
God places aid in our lives for a reason.
Sometimes the answers to our desperate prayers aren’t a divine white light shining from Heaven, immediately healing us.
Sometimes, it’s taking a tiny blue tablet every night or sitting on a lumpy couch, hugging a pillow while smelling a lemon-scented oil diffuser in the therapist’s office.
Your mental health struggles don’t define your relationship with God. He is always for you.
Talk to your doctor before starting or stopping any medication. If you’re in crisis or having thoughts of suicide, call or text 988.
